'Exchanges': Contemporary Criticism and Bosanquet's Response

supplementary volume II

  1. On Green's Ethics: [75; Reprinted in (177)]

  2. 1-1 [A.E. Taylor and Shadworth Hodgson] Discussion of "Recent Criticism of Green’s Ethics." Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.s. II (1901-1902), pp. 63-70.

    1-2 B. Bosanquet, "Reply ." Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.s. II (1901-1902), pp. 71-73.
     
     

  3. On Logic and Thinking [88; reprinted in Vol. 1]

  4. 2-1 F.C.S. Schiller, Comments on "Can Logic Abstract from the Psychological conditions of Thinking?" Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.s. VI (1905-1906), pp. 255-262

    2-2 B. Bosanquet, "Reply." Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.s. VI (1905-1906), pp. 262-65.
     
     

  5. On Cause and Ground [102; Reprinted in Vol. 1]

  6. 3-0 H.S.Shelton, "On Methods and Methodology"

    [102 - in Volume 1] "Cause and Ground." Journal of Philosophy,

    3-1 H.S. Shelton [`Cause and Ground: A Reply' Journal of Philosophy, VIII (1911), 38-41.]

    3-2 B. Bosanquet, "Cause and Ground: A Rejoinder." Journal of Philosophy, VIII (1911), pp. 41-42.

    3-3 H.S.Shelton, "Postscript" Journal of Philosophy, VIII (1911), p. 43
     
     

  7. On Mechanism [112; reprinted in Vol. 1]

  8. 4-1 [W.R. Sorley, James Ward] Comment on "Purpose and Mechanism." Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.s. XII (1911-1912), pp. ?251-261?

    4-2 B. Bosanquet, "Reply [to comment on `Purpose and Mechanism']." Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.s. XII (1911-1912), pp. 262-63.
     
     

  9. On Obligations

  10. 5-1 G.D.H. Cole, "Conflicting Social Obligations," Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.s. XV (1914-1915), pp 140-159.

    5-2 B. Bosanquet, "Note on Mr. Cole’s Paper ["Conflicting Social Obligations"]." Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.s. XV (1914-1915), pp. 160-63.
     
     

  11. On Individuality [143; reprinted in 177]

  12. 6-1 A. Seth Pringle-Pattison, G.F. Stout and R.B. Haldane," in H. Wildon Carr, ed., Life and Finite Individuality. Two Symposia. Edited for the Aristotelian Society with an introduction (London: Williams and Norgate, 1918) (later designated as Aristotelian Society Supplementary Volume I, [1918]),

    6-2 B. Bosanquet, "Reply," in H. Wildon Carr, ed., Life and Finite Individuality. Two Symposia. Edited for the Aristotelian Society with an introduction (London: Williams and Norgate, 1918) (later designated as Aristotelian Society Supplementary Volume I, [1918]), pp. 179-94.
     
     

  13. On logic

  14. 7-1 E.C. Jones, "The Import of Propositions." Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.s. XV (1914-1915), pp. 353-374.

    7-2 (123) B. Bosanquet, "The Import of Propositions." Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.s. XV (1914-1915), pp. 374-84. a response to Jones

    7-3 F.C.S. Schiller, "The Import of Propositions." Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.s. XV (1914-1915), pp. 384-397 (esp. 389-397)

    7-4 E.E.C. Jones, "Reply," Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.s. XV (1914-1915), pp. 397-412

    7-5 (124) B. Bosanquet, "Rejoinder to Dr. Schiller’s Paper [on "The Import of Propositions."]." Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.s. XV (1914-1915), pp. 412-18.

 
8-1 L.J. Russell, "??The Basis of Bosanquet’s Logic." Mind, ns. XXX (1918), pp.

8-2 B. Bosanquet, " ‘The Basis of Bosanquet’s Logic.’ " Mind, n.s. XXVIII (1919), pp. 203-12. Reprinted in large part in (154).

8-3 L.J. Russell, "The Basis of Bosanquet’s Logic." Mind, ns. XXX (1920??), pp. 472-477.

8-4 (159) B. Bosanquet, "The Basis of Bosanquet’s Logic" Mind, n.s. XXX (1921), pp. 191-194
 

9-0 BB [(___)] "Causality and Implication." Mind, n.s. XXV (1916), pp. 94-100 -- in Vol. 1]

9-1 Charles A Mercier, "Causality and Implication." Mind, n.s. XXVI (1917), pp. 77-80

9-2 "Causality and Implication." Mind, n.s. XXVI (1917), pp. 197-204. [a rejoinder to Charles A Mercier, pp. 77-80)

  10-1 C.D. Broad, "The External World"

10-2 (164) "Prof. Broad on the External World." Mind , n.s. XXXI (1922), p. 122.

10-3 C.D. Broad, "Reply to "Prof. Broad on the external World."" Mind , n.s. XXXI (1922), pp. 122-123.

11-1 G.W. Cunningham "7+5=12." Philosophical Review XXX (1922) 495-504

11-2  "7 + 5 = 12." Philosophical Review, XXXI (1922), pp. 593-98. [a response to Cunningham]
 

12-1 K. Gilbert [on humour]

12-2 (171a) "The Philosophy of Humor." Philosophical Review, XXXI (1922), p. 630.


 

On social policy

13-1. T. MacKay. "Liberty or Leading Strings: A Reply " Charity Organisation Review, VI (1890), pp. 16-19.

13-2 BB "A Rejoinder [to a reply by MacKay]." Loc cit., VI (1890), pp. 66-67.
 
 

14-1 A. Marshall, "The Poor Law in Relation to ..." Economic Journal, II (1892): 186-191

14-2 BB "The Limitations of the Poor Law." Economic Journal, II (1892), pp. 369-71.

14-3 A. Marshall, "Poor Law Reform" Economic Journal, II (1892): 371-379.