DEPARTMENT OF ANTHROPOLOGY

ST. FRANCIS XAVIER UNIVERSITY

ANTH 233 ETHNOGRAPHIC STUDIES FALL 2010

INSTRUCTOR: Dr. Susan Vincent [Office: JBB 335E; tel: 867- 5281; email: svincent@stfx.ca]

 

DESCRIPTION OF COURSE

In this course we will explore answers to the following questions: What is ethnography? What kinds of cultural information can anthropologists use to produce an ethnography? What forms can ethnography take? What are the implications of different representations? The material will range from classic ethnographic studies, to fiction, museum exhibits and visual and digital ethnography.

 

This course will build student skills in the following areas:

1) knowledge in the discipline of anthropology, specifically in ethnography.

2) critical academic reading, research and writing skills.

3) ability to identify and apply anthropological theory.

4) ability to apply anthropological frameworks to information in the public realm.

 

CLASSROOM EQUITY POLICY

For all members of our class to learn effectively, this classroom must be a safe learning environment. To ensure safety for all students, the policy in this class is that no one shall be discriminated against or harassed on the basis of age, race, colour, religion, creed, sex, sexual orientation, physical disability or mental disability, an irrational fear of contracting an illness or disease, ethnic, national or Aboriginal origin, family status, marital status, source of income, political belief, affiliation or activity, an individual's association with another individual or class of individuals having any one or more of the characteristics referred to in the list above. Whether a person intended their words or actions to be discriminatory or harassing does not matter; it is the effect of words and actions that is the focus of equitable treatment.

Discrimination is the distinctive treatment of a person with one or more of the above characteristics which, in the view of a reasonable person, has the effect of imposing a burden, obligation or disadvantage or limits and withholds benefits and advantages to an individual or a class of individuals. Harassment (including sexual harassment) is offensive or objectionable conduct or comment toward another person or persons that is known or ought to be known from the perspective of a reasonable person in the position of the complainant to be intimidating, offensive or unwelcome.

Please feel free to discuss with me any questions or concerns you have about discrimination or harassment. If I cannot help you resolve your problem, you may discuss the matter further with the Human Rights and Equity Advisor, Marie Brunelle (mbrunell@stfx.ca)

 

READINGS: Most of the readings are on on the library’s electronic database; one is on reserve at the library.

 

EVALUATION:

  • Assignment 1 (due Oct. 4): 10%

  • Assignment 2: tba 10%

  • Quiz (Oct. 18): 15%

  • Term paper (due Nov. 17): 35%

  • December exam (see official schedule): 30%

  • My responsibility is to maintain the professional and academic standards of St Francis Xavier University as well as those of my discipline as I teach course material and foster the development of critical academic reading, researching, analytical and writing skills in students. I will endeavour to do this in a way that recognizes that students have other demands on their time, and within the constraints presented by my other teaching, administrative and research duties. I will return marked assignments as quickly as I can and am happy to meet with students to discuss the course.

     

    Students have the responsibility to maintain the academic integrity of St Francis Xavier University (see Section 3.8 of the Academic Calendar and the Policy on Academic Integrity at http://www.mystfx.ca/services/registrar/academic_integrity_document.pdf) as they engage in learning the material and skills presented in the course. Students must attend class, read the required readings prior to the class in which they will be discussed, and complete assignments according to the schedule given in the course. In extraordinary circumstances supported by documentation, students may be permitted to submit assignments at a later time, although a deduction of 5 % per day may be applied. In no case will assignments be accepted after those submitted on the normal due date have been returned to their authors. Returned marked assignments must be kept until the end of the course.

     

    Tentative course schedule

    What is ethnography?

     

    Sept. 13-15: Introduction to course:

    READ: Willis, Paul and Mats Trondman (2000) "Manifesto for Ethnography." Ethnography 1(1): 5-16. Sage. URL: http://eth.sagepub.com/content/1/1/5.full.pdf+html

     

    Additional reading:

    Behar, Ruth (1993) "Women writing culture: Another telling of the story of American anthropology." Critique of Anthropology 13(4): 307-325. Sage.

    Behar, Ruth (1999) "Ethnography: Cherishing our second-fiddle genre." Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 28; 472-484. Sage. http://jce.sagepub.com/cgi/reprint/28/5/472.pdf

    Behar, Ruth (2007) "Ethnography in a Time of blurred genres." Anthropology & Humanism.

    32(2):145-155. Anthrosource.

    Burawoy, Michael (2003) "Revisits: An Outline of a Theory of Reflexive Ethnography." American Sociological Review, 68(5): 645-679. Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1519757

    Leach, Edmund (1989) "Writing Anthropology." American Ethnologist 16(1): 137-141 Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/644794

    Marcus, George E (2002) "Beyond Malinowski and after writing culture: On the future of cultural anthropology and the predicament of ethnography." The Australian Journal of Anthropology.13(2):191-200, Proquest.

    Sanjek, Roger (1991) "The Ethnographic Present." Man, New Series 26(4): 609-628. JSTOR Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2803772

    Urry, James (2006) "The Ethnographicisation of Anglo-American Anthropology: Causes and Consequences." SITES 3(2): 3-39. URL: http://sites.otago.ac.nz/index.php/Sites/article/viewFile/14/2

     

    Sept. 20-27: Writing

    An example of classical ethnography

    READ: Gluckman, Max (1968) ‘Inter-hierarchical Roles: Professional and Party Ethics in Tribal Areas in South and Central Africa’, in M.J. Swartz (ed.) Local-Level Politics: Social and Cultural Perspectives, pp. 69–93. Chicago, IL: Aldine. http://www6.ufrgs.br/horizon/files/antropolitica/gluckman_roles.pdf

    An example of contemporary ethnography

     

    READ: Bernstein, Elizabeth (2001) "The Meaning of the Purchase: Desire, Demand and the Commerce of Sex." Ethnography 2(3): 389-420.

    http://eth.sagepub.com/cgi/reprint/2/3/389

    Fiction as ethnography

     

    READ: Deloria, Ella (1988) Excerpt from Waterlily. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 141-162. Available at the library.

    Additional reading: Finn, Janet (1993) "Ella Cara Deloria and Mourning Dove: writing for cultures, writing against the grain." Critique of Anthropology 13(4): 335-349. Sage

     

    Sept. 29-Oct. 27: Visual Anthropology: Content, technology, technique, representation

    The photograph

    READ: Lutz, Catherine and Jane Collins (1991) "The photography as an intersection of gazes: The example of National Geographic." Visual Anthropology Review 7(1): 134-149. Anthrosource

     

    Additional Reading:

    Berger, John (2002) "The ambiguity of the photograph." In Kelly Askew and Richard Wilk, eds. The Anthropology of Media, A Reader. Malden, Mass. and Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 47-55.

    Bourdieu, Pierre (1991) "Towards a Sociology of Photography'." Visual Anthropology Review 7(1): 129-133. Anthrosource

    Ethnographic film: a history

     

    OCTOBER QUIZ OCTOBER 18!!!!!

     

    READ: Marks, Dan (1995) "Ethnography and Ethnographic Film: From Flaherty to Asch and after" American Anthropologist 97(2): 339-347. JSTOR

    Films: examples of some classics (In the land of the war canoes, Nanook of the North,)

     

    October 27: Ethnographic film: Technology, technique

    READ: MacDougall, David (2001) "Renewing Ethnographic Film: Is Digital Video Changing the Genre?" Anthropology Today, 17(3):15-21 Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2678157

    Film: Chronique d’un été, The Ax fight

     

    November 1-3: Visual anthropology: the impact of media and media as subject

    READ: Werner, Jean-François (2006) "How Women Are Using Television to Domesticate Globalization: A Case Study on the Reception and Consumption of Telenovelas in Senegal." Visual Anthropology 19(5): 443-472, AnthroSource. URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/08949460600961331

     

    ALSO READ: Abu-Lughod, Lila ( 1993) "Islam and Public Culture: The Politics of Egyptian Television Serials." Middle East Report. 180: 25-30. JSTOR. Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3013229

     

    Additional readings:

    Ginsburg, Faye (1994) "Culture/Media: A (Mild) Polemic." Anthropology Today 10(2):5-15. JSTOR

    MacDougall, David (1978) "Ethnographic Film: Failure and Promise." Annual Review of Anthropology 7: 405-425. JSTOR

    Ruby, Jay (1991) "Speaking for, speaking about, speaking with, or speaking alongside – an anthropological and documentary dilemma." Visual Anthropology Review 7(2): 50-67. Anthrosource.

    Ruby, Jay (2005) "The last 20 years of visual anthropology – a critical review." Visual Studies 20(2): 159-170. Taylor and Francis Journals Online.

    Wright, Chris (1998) "The Third Subject: Perspectives on Visual Anthropology." Anthropology Today 14(4):16-22 JSTOR

     

    Nov. 8- 17: Virtual anthropology: Ethnography and ICTs

    READ: Slater, Don and Janet Kwami (2005) Embeddedness and escape: Internet and mobile use as poverty reduction strategies in Ghana. Information Society Research Group. Working Paper Series. http://zunia.org/uploads/media/knowledge/internet.pdf

     

    WATCH: Wesch, Michael (2008) An anthropological introduction to YouTube.. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TPAO_lZ4_hU&feature=channel

     

    ALSO READ: Boellstoerff, Tom (2009) "Virtual worlds and futures of anthropology." AnthroNotes 30(1): 1-5. http://anthropology.si.edu/outreach/anthnote/AnthroNotesSpring2009web.pdf

     

    ALSO READ: Reed, Adam (2005) "‘My blog is me’: Texts and persons in UK online journal culture (and anthropology)." Ethnos, 70(2): 220- 242. Taylor and Francis Journals Online.

     

    ALSO READ: Bakardjieva, Maria (2003) "Virtual togetherness: an everyday-life perspective." Media, Culture and Society 25(3): 291-. http://mcs.sagepub.com/content/25/3/291- 313. Sage database.

     

    Postponed visual anthropology section:

    Ethnographic film: representation and authorship

    READ: Ruby, Jay (1995) "The moral burden of authorship in ethnographic film." Visual Anthropology Review 11(2): 77-82. Anthrosource.

    Films: Taking Aim, First Contact

     

    READ: MacBean, James Roy (1994) "Degrees of Otherness: A Close Reading of First Contact, Joe Leahy's Neighbors and Black Harvest." Visual Anthropology Review 10(2): 55_70. Anthrosource. Concentrate on the review of First Contact.

     

    ALSO READ: Wogan, Peter (2006) "Laughing at First Contact." Visual Anthropology Review 22(1):14_34 Anthrosource.

     

    ALSO READ: Hays, Terence E.(1984) "Review of First Contact,. Bob Connolly, Robin Anderson." American Anthropologist. 86(4): 1076_1077 JSTOR

     

    Nov. 22-December 1: Museum anthropology

    READ: Vogel M.L. Vanessa (1990) "The Glenbow Controversy and the Exhibition of North American Art." Museum Anthropology. 14(4): 7_11. Anthrosource.

     

    ALSO READ: Harrison, Julia. (1988) "‘The Spirit sings’ and the future of anthropology." Anthropology Today. 4(6): 6-10. JSTOR.

     

    ALSO READ: Ames, Michael M (1999) "How to Decorate a House: The Re-negotiation of Cultural Representations at the University of British Columbia Museum of Anthropology." Museum Anthropology 22(3): 41-51. Anthrosource.

     

    Additional readings:

    Brown, Alison (2002) "Review of Nitsitapiisinni: Our Way of Life. The Blackfoot Gallery, Glenbow Museum, Calgary, Alberta, Canada. Opened November 2001." Museum Anthropology 25(2): 69_75.

    Butler, Shelley Ruth (2000) "The Politics of Exhibiting Culture: Legacies and Possibilities." Museum Anthropology 23(3): 74_92

    Harrison, Julia (2005) "What Matters: Seeing the Museum Differently." Museum Anthropology, 28(2: 31_42. Anthrosource

    Phillips, Ruth B and Mark Salber Phillips. (2005) "Double Take: Contesting Time, Place, and Nation in the First Peoples Hall of the Canadian Museum of Civilization." American Anthropologist. 107(4): 694-

    Trigger, Ames, Halpin in Culture (1988) 8(1) (available on Proquest). Also see Harrison in Anthropology Today (1988; 4(6):6-10), with a response by Bruce Trigger.

    Wilson, Thomas H, Georges Erasmus and, David W. Penney (1992) "Museums and First Peoples in Canada." Museum Anthropology 16(2): 6_11. Anthrosource.

     

    December 6: Course conclusion.

     

    DESCRIPTION OF TESTS AND ASSIGNMENTS:

    Assignment 1: DUE 4 OCTOBER. This assignment gives you practice with the elements that go into essay writing in order to provide a rough template for the essay due later in the term. An essay is the presentation of an argument, in which you try to convince a reader of your point of view.

    Using the Deloria reading as the context, answer the question: "Can ethnography be presented as fiction?"

    In this assignment you will develop:

    1) an argument (the answer to the question, plus a brief reason);

    2) present the theoretical stance which helps you develop your argument (this will be your definition of "ethnography;" you will derive this from the Willis and Trondman reading);

    3) provide enough context about the Deloria reading so that a reader who does not know the article can make sense of your assignment;

    4) present evidence from the readings so far to support your argument; REMEMBER TO EXPLAIN THE EVIDENCE IN TERMS OF THE THEORETICAL STANCE!!!

    5) a conclusion, in which you review your argument and add some further inflection (e.g. "Only time will tell ...", or "Further study on _ is needed to settle this question conclusively," etc.). This assignment should be about 500 words in length and should have headings for each section. A model will be made available to you.

    Some rules:

    1) Use the style described at http://www.mystfx.ca/academic/anthropology/Essay%20Style%20Guide.html

    2) Abide by the StFX Academic Integrity Policy: (http://www.mystfx.ca/services/registrar/academic_integrity_document.pdf)

    3) You are permitted no more than ONE direct quotation from your sources, and this quotation may be no more than 30 words in length. For all other references to content from your sources you must paraphrase.

    Assignment 2: This will be an assignment on library research skills. See assignment description.

     

    Term paper: DUE 17 NOVEMBER. This assignment builds your critical research, reading, analytical and writing skills.

    Write a 7 to 10 page ESSAY answering one of the following questions.

    1) Focusing on either television or cell phones, examine the impact of this technology on a specific group of people. The Werner and Abu-Lughod readings can serve as models, but NOT as your major source material. You may use readings from the "additional readings" list on this outline, as well as other academic sources. You must have 5 ethnographic sources in your bibliography. You are very strongly encouraged to consult with me about your sources to ensure that they are appropriate.

    2) A topic of your choice, which MUST be approved by me. You could examine, for example, the recent ethnographic material on virtual worlds (Tom Boellstoerff’s Coming of Age in Second Life, along with other academic material), critically examine an ethnographic film, etc.

    Some rules:

    1) Use the style described at http://www.mystfx.ca/academic/anthropology/Essay%20Style%20Guide.html

    2) Abide by the StFX Academic Integrity Policy: (http://www.mystfx.ca/services/registrar/academic_integrity_document.pdf)

    3) You are permitted no more than THREE direct quotations from your sources, and none of these three quotations may be more than 30 words in length. For all other references to content from your sources you must paraphrase.

    You will be marked on:

    1) the quality, strength and clarity of your argument;

    2) the quality and clarity of your evidence, including the quality of the sources you use;

    3) the appropriateness of the theoretical framework and the quality of the analysis (that is, how well you use the theoretical framework to analyse the evidence);

    4) the style and structure of the paper, including proper and complete referencing, grammar, spelling, word use, sentence structure, essay structure, etc.

    Quiz and Exam: The quiz and exams will be composed of short written answer and essay questions.